it was nearly ten years ago when i first met judge mchugh when i was working for then-governor john huntsman. during his first year as governor, it was time for him to appoint someone to the utah court of appeals. at that point, the nominating commissions began their work, and shortly after their work concluded, the governor's staff started interveering the various applicants, various people who had been considered by the nominating commission. it soon became apparent that there was a real standout in this very impressive group of candidates for this court of appeals position and that judge mchugh's name rose to the top of that list. i found her in these discussions, discussions that i had with her with my colleagues and also with governor huntsman to possess a keenly insightful legal mind, and i found her to be someone who really understands the role of judges, the necessarily limited role and the crucial function of the judge in our system. she has served with great distinction on the utah court of appeals during those intervening years, and for that reason i'm confident that based on the