this is lieutenant john ryan of the port authority police.pretty much ran the site from the port authority point of view during the months i was down there and he was a great friend and helped me. one afternoon, when i was down several levels in the pit, a grappler machine reached into the rubble and pulled out some stuff and suddenly fluttering to the ground were hundreds of photographs. it was the port authority archive, bridges, tunnels, roadways, events, all of it fluttering. i asked the guy to wait a second and i ran up the hill and went looking for lieutenant ryan and i found him and he and his men went down and effectively saved the archive. three or four hours later, i bump into john on the site again. he said hey, look at this and he showed me his graduation photographs from the police academy. he had found them in the pile. the needle in the haystack. this is a woman named pia hoffman who deserves our special attention. she is the only woman operating engineer, which means she can drive any big machine, a grabler or a crane. she's l

. >> edward ryan. >> john joseph ryan, jr. >> jonathan stephan ryan. >> matthew lancelot ryan. >> tatiana ryjova. >> christina sunga ryook. >> thierry saada. >> and my uncle. we love an issue every day. >> and my father. >> jason elazar sabbag. >> thomas e. sabella. >> scott saber. >> joseph francis sacerdote. >> francis john sadocha. >> jude safi. >> brock joel safronoff. >> edward saiya. >> john patrick salamone. >> hernando salas. >> juan g. salas. >> esmerlin antonio salcedo. >> john salvatore salerno, jr. >> richard l. salinardi, jr. >> and mind niece, the lead flight attendant on united 175. she had a radiant smile, contagious laughter, boundless enthusiasm, an analyst compassion. although she may not ever be found, she will never be lost to our families and friends. we honor her by letting go of the sadness over losing her and embracing the joy of having on her. for the flight crews here with us or watching around the world, bless you and thank you for your courage and for being first on the front lines to keep us free and flying. >> and my little brother, our hero. a firefighter.

percent of republicans support the spending cuts only approach being pushed by republicans like paul ryan john boehner eric cantor so did we just see the defining issue of the two thousand and twelve election campaign to tax the rich or not to tax the rich for more on this let's turn to our panel i'm joined by heather sermon conservative strategist and associate of loose solutions and roger hickey co-director of the campaign for america's future welcome you both and thanks for joining us again thank you. first of all why do so many billionaires pay lower federal income taxes than average working people i mean among the forbes four hundred last year the average income tax rate federal income tax rate was eighteen but it was actually paid it was eighteen percent how did that how did we get here. well i think we do have loopholes that need be closed i will agree but that however the warren buffets of the world are still the rare ones you know we still do have a progressive tax code top four hundred paid an average of eighteen percent but it's not really the top one percent of current on average p

gerald fisher john roger fisher thomas j. fisher lucy a. fishman ryan d. rald thomas james fitzpatrick richard p. fitzsimons salvatore fiumefreddo christina donovan flannery eileen flecha andre g. fletcher carl m. flickinger john joseph florio joseph walken flounders >> i read it today on behalf of my brother, patrick, and my cousins, thomas collins, and of other firefighters. >> and for my father. my little sister turns 20 today and daddy would be so proud of you. david fodor michael n. fodor stephen mark fogel thomas foley david j. fontana chih min foo godwin forde donald a. foreman christopher hugh forsythe claudia alicia foster noel john foster sandra n. foster ana fosteris robert joseph foti jeffrey fox virginia fox >> dennis michael edwards. >> and my beautiful daughter and her beloved husband, peter. rest in peace, my beloved. pauline francis virgin francis gary jay frank morton h. frank peter christopher frank colleen l. frasier richard k. fraser kevin j. frawley clyde frazier, jr. lillian inez frederick andrew fredricks tamitha freeman brett owen f

john thomas mcerlean, jr. >> daniel francis mcginley >> mark ryan mcginly >> william e. mcginn >> thomas henry mcginnis >> michael gregory mcginty >> ann mcgovern >> scott martin mcgovern >> william mcgovern >> stacey sennas mcgowan >> francis noel mcguinn >> patrick mcguire >> thomas m. mchale >> and my uncle. we love you, we miss you, keep looking out for us. >> and my husband my love for you is as strong and as endless as the wedding rings we exchanged and more together. we miss you so much. >> keith mcheffey >> ann m. mchugh >> denis j. mchugh iii >> dennis mchugh >> michael e. mchugh >> robert g. mcilvaine >> donald james mcintyre >> stephanie marie mckenna >> barry j. mckeon >> evelyn c. mckinnedy >> darryl leron mckinney >> george patrick mclaughlin, jr. >> robert c. mclaughlin, jr. >> gavin mcmahon >> robert d. mcmahon >> edmund mcnally >> daniel w. mcneal >> and my father, we miss you and levy. >> and my brother, a family man, a navy man, a holy man. god is holding you in the palm of his hand. >> walter arthur mcneil >> jisley mcnish >> christine sheila mcnulty

john roger fisher >> thomas j. fisher >> lucy a. fishman >> ryan d. fitzgerald >> thomas james fitzpatrick >> richard p. novan flannery >> eileen flecha >> andre g. fletcher >> carl m. flickinger ew flocko. >> john joseph florio >> joseph walken flounders writes i read on behalf of my brother, patrick doyer, and my cousin, collins, gregory, and martin mcwilliams. >> and for my father and my little sister who turns 20 today. daddy would be so proud of you. >> david fodor >> michael n. fodor >> stephen mark fogel >> thomas foley >> thomas foley

ryan. >> todd antione isaac. >> erik isbrandtsen. >> taizo ishikawa. >> aram iskenderian, jr. >> john f.yan. >> kazushige ito. >> aleksandr valeryevich ivantsov. >> virginia may jablonski. >> brooke alexandra jackman. and my husband. thank you for the pennies. we love the finding them. you are in our hearts forever. >> and your father and i, we miss you terribly. your wife, your son, and your beloved daughter. >> aaron jeremy jacobs. >> ariel louis jacobs. >> jason kyle jacobs. >> michael grady jacobs. >> steven a. jacobson. >> ricknauth jaggernauth. >> jake denis jagoda. >> yudh vir singh jain. >> maria jakubiak. >> ernest james. >> gricelda e. james. >> priscilla james. >> mark steven jardim. >> muhammadou jawara. >> francois jean-pierre. >> maxima jean-pierre. >> and to my little brother, we love and miss you. we will always live our lives to the last. >> and to my father. you are my hero and i love you forever. i will never forget you. love you, dad. >> paul edward jeffers. >> alva cynthia jeffries sanchez. >> joseph jenkins, jr. >> alan keith jensen. >> prem n. jerath. >> farah jeud

ryan williams and john harris will moderate the republican presidential debate at the reagan library here at the top of this hour, 8 eastern, here on msnbc. you got watch msnbc tonight. you have to no choice. coming up, with his job approval rating at a new low, what has happened to president obama? can he recapture the vote and change he promised in tomorrow night's speech before the congress. you're watching "hardball." from the ronald reagan presidential library. where the republican candidates debate tonight only on msnbc. ♪ ♪♪ ♪ [ male announcer ] unlike some car companies, nissan is running at 100%, which means the most innovative cars are also the most available cars. nissan. innovation for today. innovation for all. ♪ i know you're worried about making your savings last and having enough income when you retire. that's why i'm here -- to help come up with a plan and get you on the right path. i have more than a thousand fidelity experts working with me so that i can work one-on-one with you. it's your green line. but i'll be there every step of the way. call or come in and tal

we've seen both john boehner and now paul ryan, two very influential figures in the house republicanve said, no, the super committee shouldn't touch taxes. well, who's going to do tax reform if they don't do it? >> it's a good question. now, there are a few small areas of common ground between the republicans and obama. they would both like to see corporate tax reform. republicans would like to lower corporate taxes more than obama would. >> boehner will argue you can't do that without doing the personal tax. too many people -- individuals hide under llcs and things like that. >> there will be that. plus there's the issue of what do you do about all the foreign money that's waiting over there that companies would like to bring back. but the main problem is that obama when he does tax reform wants to raise additional revenue in the process. the republicans don't. i think that today's deficit is most important because it determines whether or not the president manages to get his jobs -- short-term jobs program through. that depends in part on finding these deficit offsets. if he doesn'

volunteer actors are john lithgow, morgan freeman and rob ryan. >>> coming up next, a study that blasts a spongebob squarepants cartoon balancing screen time for kids. >>> solyndra's downfall has a trickledown effect on other bay area companies, a closer look coming up. ,, energy company solyndra of fremont went bankrupt. allen martin responds to a cbs-5 closer look at t >> congress presses for answers next week about how solyndra went bankrupt. we will look at the ripple effect of other businesses when solyndra shut down. >> now we're sitting in the dark waiting for more news from the bankruptcy court. >> a congressional the economy has issues but so does mike el segundo. >> we didn't have any notice. >> like the 1100 solyndra employees paid off, the brothers and their advantage metal products are left high and dry now that the solar panel maker failed even after receiving a $535 million federal loan guarantee. >> we had pushed in the last quarter to get their shipments out on the final production line assembly products to get them into 100% go motion to produce solar panels. >> advant

john a. rockefeller. there was no restrictions on campaign donations. ryan could not get that kind of money. he had to go out and campaign for himself. he could not campaign on a large machine. he was a wonderful person and he loved to speak. he made necessity as a virtue. he had to go on passenger trains. he spoke as many as 6000 times and that campaign. for him, this was an opportunity to become known. also the only chance he had to reach americans directly. >> he is the first campaigner to use the road in this way and campaign across the country. stephen douglas had done something similar in 1860. he was trying to take up campaigns through the south and through parts of the north. for the most part, american presidential candidate sat on their front porch and other people campaigned for them. brian campaigned at every town in illinois, ohio, virginia and traveled all over america bringing his campaign to the people pu. >> as always, we want to hear from you. we are and lincoln, nebraska. this is referred to as fairview. let's take a step back. he ran for the house of representatives, and

john: shu hires. the giants are shaken up. >> mike: i -- the giants are in a must-win situation against the diamondbacks. ryanvogelsong on the hill. star wars day an at&t. fun for everyone until the game began. the force is with the giants early. cody ross and his light saber gets to hudson with a hans solo shot to left. 1-0 giants. ryan vogelsong was the giants jedi. not happy with the call. gets tossed. then comes out of the dugout like a storm trooper and had to be restrained by his manager. the d-backs get all darth vader on the giants. the solo shot ties the game. the force was with them. four in the eighth. to more more on this triple by willie black quests. the giants a season-high six back. >> it's critical we take the series. we all know it. we didn't. so no we head down to san diego, and we're still breathing. we're hanging by a thread. i'd say. so. >> not eliminated. so anything can happen. saw the phillies come back when they were down with 17 to go. so anything can happen. >> mike: a's looking to sweep the mariners. bottom five, 3-1 a's. allen says let's tack one on. it's an rbi double. here come

irvine ryan todd antione isaac erik isbrandtsen taizo ishikawa aram iskenderian, jr. john f.shige ito aleksandr valeryevich ivantsov virginia may jablonski brooke alexandra jackman aaron jeremy jacobs >> and my husband, donald. thank you for the pennies. but kayla and i love of finding them. i love you. you are in our hearts forever. >> your father and i, we miss you terribly. your son and your beloved daughter miss you as well. >> ariel louis jacobs jason kyle jacobs michael grady jacobs steven a. jacobson ricknauth jaggernauth jake denis jagoda yudh vir singh jain maria jakubiak ernest james gricelda e. james priscilla james mark steven jardim muhammadou jawara francois jean-pierre maxima jean-pierre >> and to marlette -- my little brother. we love and miss you. we will live our lives with you in our hearts. >> and my father. i am told i look just like you. i will never forget you. love you, dad. >> paul edward jeffers john jenkins alva cynthia jeffries sanchez joseph jenkins, jr. alan keith jensen prem n. jerath farah jeudy hweidar jian eliezer jimenez, jr. luis jimenez, j

. >>> why is ryan gosling's rumored girlfriend eva mendes in a heroin den? >>> johnand i like to think of myself as a typical long island mom. >> your first look at the "long island medium." >> i talk to the dead. >> i just thought that she was crazy. >>> now, from hollywood, "the insider" is on.

john leslie albert. >> jeeda alderman. >> jacquelyn frederick. >> barrett aldreg. >> eric allen. >> joseph ryan allen. >> richard dennis allen. >> richard l. allen. >> christopher e. alingham. janet marie alonzo. >> edison alvarado. >> antonio alvarez and my uncle, james jr., we miss you. >> and my beautiful daughter, laura angilletta. we love you, we miss you. [speaking italian] >> alver. >> caesar. >> tareese. >> angela. >> james m. amratto. christopher charles amiarosa. >> calisto ania jr. >> joseph p.ankundia. yvette constance anderson. michael rorke andrews. >> my best friend, my mentor and my father, michael george achinski. if you had a chance to meet by little brother, you'd be proud. >> and my big brother, richard xavier aria naueh. >> joseph john angelina jr. >> david lawrence angel. >> mary lynn angel. doreen angasani. >> peter paul apollo. >> acino apostle jr. >> frank thomas aglinno. >> patrick michael aaronose. michael george arinnski. >> louis arena. >> barbara jean, arstety. >> adam p. arias. >> michael j. armstrong. >> last but not least, one of the best ballers in the world, mr. james aldfred, we love and m

marine general john allen commanding nato forces conceded the militants won a propaganda victory. but the american ambassador ryancker rejected comparisons to the communist tet offensive in vietnam, in 1968. >> you know, this really is not a very big deal. it was a hard day for the embassy and my staff, who behaved with enormous courage and dedication. but look, you know, a half a dozen r.p.g. rounds from 800 meters away that isn't tet offensive, that's harassment. >> sreenivasan: crocker accused the haqqani network-- based in pakistan-- of carrying out the assault. officials in iran sent mixed signals today about the fate of two american hikers arrested in 2009 and convicted of spying. the judiciary system said it is still reviewing bail for shane bauer and josh fattal. it gave no indication when a decision would come. just yesterday, president mahmoud ahmadinejad said a court had set bail of $500,000 dollars apiece and the two would be freed within days. nasa has unveiled the general plans for its powerful new rocket to take astronauts into deep space. shown in this animation, the giant space launch system woul

very well led with both ryan crocker and general john allen there. steady security progress over the last couple of years. since we put 10,000 marines in helmand in the summer of 2009. and if you were to go to helmand now our kandahar now and compare to what it was, it's vastly different. rooting out the taliban of their own internal safe havens in their country. clearly our focus -- i tried to focus this on the region. this isn't just about afghanistan. this is the region. the two countries most -- draw most focus, afghanistan and pakistan, but it's bigger than that. i mean, it's about india. it's about the stance. it's about the neighbor. it's about iron. it's about china. the totality of the region is what i think we all need to focus on responsibly so that it doesn't deter yor ate either in a civil war, a failed state with nuclear weapons which is a huge danger to the future, not just of the region but i think of the world. so obviously lots of focus there and still lots of work to be done there. on the afghanistan side while we've made improveme

a very well led with both ryan crocker and general john allen there. steady progress over the last couple years since we put 10,000 marines in helmand in the summer of '09 and if if you were to go to helmand or kandahar now and compare it to where it was, it's vastly different, rooting out the taliban of their own internal safe havens in their country. clearly, i've tried to focus this on the region. this isn't just about afghanistan. this is the region. the two countries -- that draw most focus, obviously, afghanistan and pakistan, but it's bigger than that. to me it's about india. it's about the stand. it's about its neighbor, it's about iran, it's about china. the totality of the region is what we need to focus on responsibly so that it doesn't deteriorate into either a civil war, a failed state with nuclear weapons, which is a huge danger to the future, not just of the region but i think of the world. so, obviously, lots of focus there and still lots of work to be done there. on the afghanistan side, while we've made improvements in security, clear

ryan plan right now. let's talk a little bit about john huntsman's job plan. to see a balanced budget amendment get rid of all tax expenditures, repeal obama care, expand sources of domestic energy, work on international trade agreements and so on and on. as andrea did point out, something i looked at it and i liked it as well, he lowers all the tax. >> by saturday, he'll be for keeping the home mortgage deductions. >> the tax plan is not his problem. the problem is he's more moderate on social issues which will make it tough for him to win a g.o.p. primary. he believes in civil unions and cap and trade. a lot of issues that i think will be problematic for him. he does have a little bit of an energy problem. however, he was in an reo speedwagon cover band, give him credit for that called wizards. >> steve, before you go, do you believe jay carney saying yesterday, yeah, it's just a coincidence that we scheduled this joint session of congress on the same night as -- >> completely. >> do you think it was a coincidence? >> absolutely. total coincidence. >> that's

ryan, move. he's shooting at us now. >> okay, all right. >> he's shooting at us. he has an automatic weapon. he's shooting anybody he's wearing a red shirt. >> red shirt and long johns>> he was sitting in a restaurant. >> we have officers on the way. >> we don't know if anybody is injured. he came out of the ihop. he was walking back behind locals barbecue after he did a shooting in there. i don't know what is going on. i'm not going to go outside and look. >> i don't want you to do that. megyn: trace gallagher has more live in our west coast newsroom with the new details in 4 this case. trace that is chilling. >> reporter: we believe that is the owner of the locals barbecue place that gave so many chilling accounts yesterday of exactly what happened. the motive in this case still remains very unclear, but we're finding a lot more troubling information about exactly what happened inside that international house of pancakes. one of the people inside was a woman named ethlyne mcdonald. she says the shooter came into the restaurant, he walked to the back, he began shooting and then he narrowed his aim toward those five national guard members. the sheriff a short time a

spokesman for his boss, speaker john boehner says they're going to continue to work on a responsible plan that can pass the house which is interesting since congressman paul ryanleaders knew they didn't have the votes to pass this but brought it to the floor anyway so the house could work its will. across the aisle, democratic minority leader nancy pelosi has an idea. she thinks the republicans should bring to the floor and separately the bipartisan disaster relief package already passed by the senate. disaster relief was a big sticking point here and to that point, white house communications director dan pfeiffer tweeted yesterday. "we are pleased that the house of representatives today rejected efforts to put politics above the needs of communities impacted by disasters." and to avoid a shutdown, the house and the senate are going to need to agree on something by next friday. back to you guys. >> all right, thanks very much, peter, for being on top of that story for us. we appreciate it. well, guess what? we've talked a on this show about unions and pensions and some of those payouts that have been happening. and now it turns out that in the city of chicago,