membership well let's discuss this independence bit with jonathan shafi he's a co-founder of scotland's radical independence campaign what david cameron has called a man without a plan and he is right. well i think that in fact the opposite is true because what we are seeing now throw this discussion i think is a government waste minister which is deeply panicked and deeply worried about the situation it's a measuring scotland we've seen since the turn of the new year opinion posing creasing win favor of a yes vote and therefore i don't think it's any surprise that we've seen all of the waste minister parties gang up and that's sort of fashion and i think display some quite offensive behavior when it comes to the question of the cons of course it's not in the part of you of the treasury or of george osborne to decide what counts it's gotten uses i think this is a deeply cynical and offensive political maneuver that's been undertaken by a panicked waste minister is it not westminster that should decide what happens to the british pound and who should actually use it well of course you ca