to be guided by the cabinet and the other officers who had been present, and when judge advocate joseph holt brought me the papers, including the death warrants, i signed them. some two years later, 1867, now, it is interesting, this is when the secession of the -- i'm sorry, the impeachment crisis was emerging. the newspapers began printing the awareness that a recommendation of clemency had been made, and that i had ignored it, and i sent to the war department requesting to see those documents, and when i did see them, it appeared to me that the clemency recommendation, which was right there, had been torn out and reattached, and i thought only two men could have done such a thing. one of them, joseph holt, judge advocate general who had been responsible for the trial, but the other was his superior edwin stanton. so perhaps i will leave it this way. the next day after i saw those documents from the war department, i sent a short note to secretary stanton which read, dear sir. public considerations of high character constrain me to inform you that your resignation as secretary of war will