appreciate it, mr josephina. thank you, president swig, and i'm glad we clarified about that there is an opening to the attic. under the new plan , correct it just a lot. it's a ladder. um i have never heard of a city body going so far as to tell a property owner. but they can't they can only go to a certain parts of the property for certain reasons. but the question i have is in the um in our motion. it says the dining room shall not be allowed to be converted to a home office. consequently the plans must be revised to remove the walls at this location and the 12 inch window that is located in the 13 inch space. can you show me on the new plans where that is? actually, actually, i couldn't find it. so this is this is the kitchen and the wall was here. and the and the window. we're talking about their proposed putting a window in right here. and the part about the yeah. and this is this is the countertop and were and where the where the walls removed. i believe they were walls here. okay so great. so now they're

thank you, commissioner limburg commissioner josephina. thank you, president swig and thank you again. commissioner lindbergh for your leadership on this letter. i appreciate your taking, uh, and accepting the suggested revisions, um that would that we had that we have offered. i also agree that this letter should should be sent. it's not. it's not a letter about supervisor ronan. it's about a matter that came before us about property in her district. and i heard the supervisor ronan's representative, and it sounds like supervisor. ronan has a very strong view about about the about the appellant's. i think that's fine. that demonstrates some engagement in this ah ah and i also from from the letter i hope that in an abundance of transparency, the letter from supervisor on and as part of the part as part of the record references, and i believe supervisor ronan's representative alluded to her her offices and the previous supervisors involvement for over 10 years. and this issue has not gone away. there's various, very appropriate for the supe