the work of josh goodman shows each extra year of math education upping the minimum years increased adult earnings by 8%, okay in big payoff to actually having quantitative skills. the other thing we know that has had effect, many charter schools have been quite successful. we have lottery results in boston that have shown this. i'm enough of an economist to believe in competition and innovation in the that is chartr schools and make that happen. that being said, right, we cannot forget on the public system as a whole, the most critical ingredient we know in schools is teachers. it's all about the human capital. it's at the teacher level. to me, public school teachers are heroes. the people that go in every day and fight in very difficult conditions to make lives were br for people who are starting with less. the work of my colleagues looks at the impact of teachers on test scores and compares it with the impact of those same teachers on earnings as adults. and even though the impact of teachers on test scores peters out over years, the impact of teachers on earnings does not. and we all