together and 12 d-1 05, six, seven and eight all regarding the property at 530 -- street and by josh snider and dennis steward regard ago protesting thishance of august 20th 2012 to brandon fox to the permit to demolish a building of single residence with one thousand 30 feed feet of ground floor area and protesting thishance of august 20th to a building four story two unit building with 4,015 feet of ground floor area these matters were heard on october 17th 2012 and allowed the commissioner to participate in the if i am vote however two things have changed since the board continued these matters for the reason country is that we have commissioner honda joining us and two is that we have the party have engaged on some discussions to try to narrow the issues of dispute and so with the president's consent we can giveth each party a few minutes to address the board. i think we could start perhaps it's best to start with the permit holder in this case since they have alternate plans to propose. >>> that would be good. >> so three minute? >> three minutes precise. >>> commissioners a little bla

josh baker snider that you thank you for having us back to the continue ages and the initial agreeable solution and vice president phoning was worried about the bright light issue and so i made a good fate effort to cross that line and strive for compromise and prepare to radios a top story and improve building aesthetic and is unfortunately the i consistently found that the probability sponsor was not up front about and misrepresented the changes that were made and to look back at that, i'll point out some of those issues. there were 33 issues and i'll go through them in increasingly order of supports the first is rather of the building is improved and that is acceptable and i thank you for the good work on it the second issue the appearance of the front of the building and there has been no substantive change to the front of the building and i have here side-by-side the only and new plans on the projector and you can see that they look the same we had asked some articulation and there are some minor moves and i see no substantive progress here and the most important issue is the buil