, second, you know, choosing between karamzin and midinsky, i would still vote for the benefit of kamzinte, after all, politics is relevant and less, and common sense is more than in the midin textbook, and even more so you can make a certain such uh well, you can make a discount on what karamzin wrote more than 200 years ago, but in general it is obvious that in russia it is not a state view of the past, it is rather an exception that happens extremely rarely and only in periods of m. the view of the people almost immediately after the transin, the history of the russian people of the field was published, but this multi-volume volume did not enjoy such fame as karamzin's history of the russian state . it is obvious that the course of russian history was written not so much from the state positions, but from the social ones. klyuchevska's experiments with non-state history are actually quite interesting took place in the 20s, when, on the one hand , communism actually nullified all imperial traditions

second, you know, choosing between karamzin and midinsky, i would still give my vote in favor of kamzinstate, after all, politics is relevant and less and more common sense than in midinsky's textbook, and all the more so you can make a certain kind of... well, you can make a discount on what karamzin wrote more than 200 years ago, but in general it is obvious that russia does not have a state view of the past, it is rather an exception that happens extremely rarely and only in periods of weakening of the state, which also in fact happens not often, it is obvious that it would be an exaggeration to say that in russia history was never written there, let's say from the point of view of the people, almost immediately after the transin , the history of the russian people of the field came out, but this multi-volume book did not enjoy such fame as karamzin's history of the russian state. it is obvious that klyuchevsk's russian history course was written not so much from the state positions as from social ones. quite interesting experiments were actually conducted with non-state history in t