it's going to view on this from kashyap from human rights watch in mumbai welcome to you how significant would this be for india if it happened. thank you so much yes this is a historic moment. u.s. president signaling that he's going to put people's lives and how 1st it's a very strong message and extremely important one coming at a time which is they tire for india at india and south africa have put forward this proposal we've gotten a silver it's been over 7 months and it's installed at the video and we really hope that this will move bytes swiftly into negotiations which we will also text quite transparently and as a strong outcome that allows all countries to kill up manufacturing in practical terms sorry so no no you've done that was exactly the point i was about to come to the practical terms how long if if say the decision was given now or tomorrow how long would it take for india to actually be able to scale up production on this on this scale. so there are 23 things you have to have to operate in parallel track on the one side you need the chips we have a proposal what that we