but kasick's plan relies on government revenue assumptions that experts call absurd.n this night outside of the debate hall, protesters demanded a raise to the minimum wage, inside ben carson justified his opposition with this. >> every time we raise the minimum wage the number of jobless people increases. >> reporter: but history does not support that claim. since 1979 congress has raised the minimum wage 11 times. according to labor day ta there have been overall job growth six times and overall job losses five. florida senator marco rubio in explaining his opposition to the minimum wage tried to shift the focus to something he supports, vocational training. >> welders make more money than philosophers. >> reporter: the problem is according to the bureau of labor stithics, welders age is 36,000, if is -- philosophers $63,000. >> i have met vladimir putin in a private meeting. >> reporter: on the tonight show two months ago, she said it was a more casual green room meeting. >> i met him in beijing, we were in sort of a green room setting. >>> donald trump and jeb bus

only one candidate had a bad night and that was john kasick who argued the whole time. >> martha: grumpyhe board for you. he feels like his message is not getting across. he wants to be clear he has something to say up there. it is interesting to see the different opinions pining up there. i don't know how we will do as a result of this, chris. >> reporter: i do. but we don't have to talk about that right now. ben carson had a very good night in the sense he may not be ted cruz, tremendous debate champion and courtroom dare devil, but he answered the questions effectively and turned it around on hillary clinton very well. he got done what he needed to do. but rubio and cruz continue to be the class of the election and they continue to improve and i think you will see them in the drivers seat at some point. >> martha: yeah, you said you liked having eight people. someone wishes it was nine people, clearly. i want to play sound from him because he was in the undercard debate. >> the bottom line is believe me, hillary clinton is coming for your wallet. don't worry about huckabee or jindel.