instead i am joined by three viewers of the programme, kate walsh and james sinister and in our edinburghalex cameron. thank you to all of you for coming on news watch. let's start with the issue of the shouting turn of the programme, kate, you have been in the question time audience, how did you find it? the actual audience i was in the spine andi the actual audience i was in the spine and i have noticed, and this is before fiona bruce, a blaina blame at her door, that the audiences have been getting more rowdy in calling out and shouting out, and i remembera rowdy in calling out and shouting out, and i remember a few occasions when david dimbleby actually injected people from the studio, they were so rough and ready about things. and itjust lowers the tone of the whole thing. it doesn't become a debate, it becomes a shouting match. we raise concerns about the turn of the show with the bbc and this is what they had to say,... question time generates strong views and opinions on panel and audience. alex cameron, what do you have to say about the tone of the discussion on question time?|j

kate. >> and that may be a minefield. thanks barbara. outfront joan walsh national affairs correspondent for the nation and mark lotter director of communications for the trump campaign. thank you for being here. mark we heard kellyanne conway speak today saying the president will be talking abouts successes of the administration. this moment -- that by definition is political. i mean traditionally presidents don't take part in the celebration to avoid this. convince us all this isn't about politics and running for re-election. >> i tell you this is about celebrating america and also about celebrating our military. i mean, when our founding fathers at the end of the declaration of independence said that they pledged their lives, fortune and sacred honor they knew it took more than a piece of paper to get that independence. it would take men, heroes willing to take up arms and fight for it. we still have that fight today for freedom, not only of this country but around the world. i think it's right to showcase the military and the great things they are doing