katie nicholl. and so ultimately the decision that the thacker jury took was based on the procedural flaws she vacated, the decision of the atomic energy commission on the basis that with it deviated from the regulations of the commission. and so, yeah, that that, that essentially is why that she ultimately made the decision last december to issue this. and it was extraordinary for secretary energy to revisit an atomic energy commission decision. but at the or the present moment live in and the heat is the sheer volume of just historical record that has built up over the last seven years made it practically impossible for her not to render such a decision you provided a memo. would you like to walk us through the 1954 aec memo that you provide? you know, if you can not put enough, i can talk about that. so this memo that i found, the archives, i think kind of sums it up. so this memo was issued in january 1950 or a good three months before. the oppenheimer hearing only kicked off and it was a memo w