. >> legally, keisha, i go back to judge pauly's decision and he buried it on like page 42, but the fundamentalect was when you share information with a third party there is no right to privacy. >> one of the things i thought about was a cell phone carrier and they do retain the information. so having a third party keep that data is like your telephone company having that information and it is not the same. >> what do you think about that? this is going to go to the supremes, right? >> yes. correct me if i am wrong, but there are two judges with diverse opinions. and so that right there, you and i as lawyers know ultimately this will get up to the supremes. ultimately, here is the thing. i think if you ask most americans like i said earlier do we want to be kept from the bad guys? yes. to take all of our information without the consent and as you said that that third party now once it is delegated out, the right of privacy is gone and how do we know how it is being used? that's the problem. we don't. if they say, well, that's my concern, how is it being used if at all? >> right. but bob, one of