the court case has been dismissed due to the statute of limitation which has been raised by keke although kate previously had been saying that they are also really interested in the merits of the case and clarifying the standards of liability the court did not decide on that at all so that means to the whole question of to which extend do european based companies. have responsibility of toward staff suppliers is completely up in the air so the president that you were hoping for could not be said do you think this trial nevertheless an impact on a different scale. yes so the merits have not been decided which still means that the whole industry needs to be on their toes because when ever there is a new tick factory disaster the next claim will be brought and we will again ask the courts to make a decision on liability questions also the case has been putting so much pressure on cake that they were willing to pay in total six million u.s. dollars in an out of court negotiation. and i think at least for the german debate this case has also highlighted that we are desperately in need of better law