one in 19-20, and one in the third year. >> supervisor cohen: i'm just trying -- you'll be back on monday. kelly, do me a favor. i need you to write that down and have that in a table. >> happy to. >> supervisor cohen: so we can follow this. >> you bet. >> supervisor cohen: this is a very serious issues because when you're hiring officers, this is more than just a one-time expense. this is going to be a cost that grows exponentially as the officer continues to serve san francisco and therefore. thank you -- there after. thank you. this is absolutely incredibly important, and as i said, i'm just trying to understand the exact roundness number of 250, so i'm not quite there, chief. and the document that you provided is actually -- this document right here is very helpful because it helps me understand a little bit as to -- this is, like, best case scenario. if you had everything that you wanted, this is exactly how you would break people out and deploy your officers. >> correct. >> supervisor cohen: now i have some other questions when it comes to management. and i don't know -- i don't know all o

cohen, we're only adding 150 officers. i had a slide, and it was in my presentation last week, that breaks out that 250 that you had requested, so i know that kelly is going to be presenting that to you, another breakdown, but it's 150 new positions over four years. >> supervisor cohen: 150 or 145? >> 145. >> supervisor cohen: so you want to add 145 new positions, and what is the cost of adding 145 new positions? >> it's approximately 21 million. >> supervisor cohen: right. so let's get back to what we're talking about on the budget committee, let's talk about the numbers. so we're talking about approximately $21 million, and let's put this in perspective. we've got home health care workers that many people have also advocates for, they're asking for $15 an hour, and they are asking for $34 million. we're talking about $21 million to add 145 new positions, and kelly, correct me if i am wrong, it does include retirement and benefits? >> yeah. in the budgeted costs there, it does include retirement costs on behalf of the city, however, the long-term retirement obligations for the entire life of the officer are incorporated into our five year financ

thank you very much. [ gavel ]. >> supervisor cohen: thank you, miss kelly. [please stand by] >> supervisor cohen: that captured a very large number of people. i recommend we increase funding for senior services to help seniors continue to live in their home and for workforce development. these are issues that my colleagues have highlight. i want to welcome any suggestion on how that funding could be more specifically -- should be more specifically allocated as they are fairly high levels. i suggest that we allocate more funding to mental health services. which i directed towards homeless individual and family. i would welcome any of your feedback if it should be more or less. i suggested a significant one time investment in year two for open voting. the elections commissions requested $4 million which would be matched -- actually i'm sor sorry, advocacy group requested $4 million matched by the state and department of election indicated they need to do more study over the remaining coming year to create a use or rollout plan for that money. that's why i am ho

kelly? >> supervisor cohen: 5.5 million is where we're at total. okay. thank you. thank you for that reminder -- over two years. supervisor yee? >> it's 4.9 for the first year. we're at -- [inaudible] >> okay. so -- you're correct. >> supervisor cohen: okay. supervisor yee? >> supervisor yee: you asked me a question about the 125. that's actually not my request, when i think about it, because the funding i put in there was from last year, so that's already in there. and there was a commitment at the time that they would match it from last year's budget, so i don't know what this is for. >> supervisor cohen: okay. so thank you for that. what is the 125 workload study? 125,000? >> i'm sorry, can you repeat the question? >> supervisor cohen: sure. so my question was there's $125,000 allocated for a workload study, and supervisor yee indicated that that money was allocated in last year's budget, and there was an undering that you would match that allocation. now, we have before us a request for an additional 125,000 for a workload study. i was under the impression that

cohen. alex? >> kelly o'donnell thank you so much. e you again today. >>> joining me now, "washington post" reporter eugene scott and cnbc editor at large john harwood. good morning to you both. eugene, with you here first, michael cohen recording his conversations and the president's response. how concerning is this for the white house realistically? >> realistically quite concerning because it appears the president was not aware he had been recorded by his former personal attorney, and so it's very possible there are more tapes, and he know -- knowing what he could have been talking about with cohen, it's probably concern that some of those conversations are on tape and could contribute some of the things he's told the americans and alleged affairs payments to the "national enquirer" other organizations and individuals and other accesses and words that could bring his ethics and the legality of his behavior into question. >> yeah. you've got to think, though, the president, as everybody else is, john, wondering how, just logistically

let's go now to the secret recording make by michael cohen. kelly o'donnell, any reaction from the white house on all of this? >> well, i saw "red sparrow" on an airplane, too. no official reaction from the white house, we have seen an outside manner, they represent the lawyers on the outside. that includes rudy giuliani. they spoke about the fact that this was a conversation that was short in length, that according to giuliani would be exculpatory giving the president a defense that there was discussion of including a proper paper trail if it was to happen. we don't know what else is on the fap, we don't know if it really is exculpatory. it is the first lady's office when asked about her plans this weekend and reaction to this story, they say she is here for the weekend with her family, but they described her as having no comment on this subject. she is focused on being a mother and first lady of the united states. so the white house is trying to parse this out. that makes rudy juliani -- giuliani the spokes person. and there are pieces of the stor

cohen. would tapeli we get more from the white house and our correspondent kelly o'donnell. >> reporter: new lows in a high-stakes split. today the president lashed out at his long-time secret keeper. >> i want to tell you about the real donald trump. >> reporter: former personal attorney michael cohen. the president tweeted, "inconceivable that a lawyer would tape a client. totally unheard of and perhaps illegal." fury directed at cohen, who recorded a conversation with then candidate trump about a possible payoff for "playboy" model karen mcdougal, who says she had a ten-month relationship with trump back in 2006. the recording among evidence seized during an fbi raid on cohen in april, when the president was sympathetic. >> so i just heard that they broke into the office of one of my personal attorneys. good man. >> reporter: today sources close to cohen say that trump recording had been off limits to the fbi under attorney-client privilege but now investigators can listen because the president gave up that protection. the tape's existence blew up in the media friday. >> we have breaking

look to his current lawyer confirms the payments were discussed with cohen but says they were never made a white house correspondent kelly how could reports. this recording seems to reveal the president discussing with his personal attorney michael cohen the payment of money in the form of check fully one hundred fifty thousand dollars this is problematic for the president given that he has denied he ever had an affair with karen mcdougal the playboy model the white house saying this was fake news and that the president never had such a relationship the recording seems to contradict that statement of course the president at the time of this alleged affair also married with an infant son certainly problematic on a personal level so this really brings up the question of what the president knew and when he knew it it's also a concern given the fact that there is a separate investigation that is ongoing in all of this and that is the one being conducted by robert muller the special counsel well these two investigations are separate the one into michael cohen trumps personal attorney and the one into whether or not there was

. >> supervisor cohen: oh, thank you. kelly kirk patrick. >> thank you. i know the department is anxiously awaiting the rebalancing plan. we have been working closely with the department and we will be planning to come out with that monday morning, and i apologize. i know it's important but we've been working really hard. and i know that ensuring the continuation of the 18-19 funding that is in the h.s.h. budget as well as the programs that you stated, i understand those are priorities for the committee. >> supervisor fewer: thank you very much. >> supervisor cohen: all right. thank you for definitely setting the record straight. we will continue the conversation on monday. i just, colleagues, want you to recognize that the director will be with us for a short period of time, but if the hearing goes along, which i anticipate it to be, then he has designated representatives to speak on his behalf. so we thank you for your time coming here, i want to make a motion that we expect the baseline cuts, and can i have a second by supervisor yee, and we'll take th

cohen has. issure you of that. >> start with kelly o'donnell. not far from where the president is spending the weekend at his bedminster resort. good morning. the president refused to answer questions on camera about michael cohen and that infamous meeting at trump tower with the russian lawyer. still, we keep asking what did he know and when did he know it? >> reporter: these are persistent questions, alex, and the president commented in his own way but not engaged with reporters when we have been asking about this issue. it is important in understanding what the president's knowledge was, what his role may have been, what the intentions were when that meeting in 2016 was taken, and the fact that the stories have changed over time, and once considered an ally, michael cohen now appears to be squarely in the camp of being a threat to the president. but there's credibility issues all around. which one of the figures in this is to be believed? now, this comes at a time when the president also has other things on this mind like the economy, and impr

cohen: okay. thank you. kelly, we have a question for you. supervisor stefani has one for you. >> supervisor stefani: yes. if you could just expand on what supervisor yee just said in terms of why it wasn't in the mayor's budget. it sounds like that request was made. >> on 18-19, there's the 15 that everybody is on board with, right? and then, there's the 700,000 that is in the mayor's proposed budget which gets to six new vehicles. you know, we do have a limited equipment budget, and we try our best to allocate to the extent we can, and so we were able to fund 21 in the mayor's budget, and so i believe we support the fire department's need for these vehicle replacements and the critical needs they've identified. >> supervisor cohen: do you have a question? supervisor yee -- i'm sorry, just give me a second. b.l.a., is there anything else you need -- any other remarks, still? okay. supervisor yee, can you make a motion, please? >> supervisor yee: i'd like to make a motion -- actually, i don't even know what the motion is. >> supervisor cohen:

. >> let's start with one of the big headlines this week as kelly was talking about michael cohen claiming that trump knew about the meeting at trump tower. it seems like a complete falling out of the two close allies. how concerned with trump's lawyers with the latest claim by cohen and by cohen in general? >> it is really a striking falling out between the president and his former to attorney who has been his finx - figur fixer for a decade. the president is trying to prevent him from being a credible witness with the prosecutors. >> phil, as we heard from kelly o. putin inviting president trump to moscow. sarah sanders says the president is open to doing that. how eager are officials for president trump to go to moscow to meet putin? how likely is it to happen? >> i think ultimately it will happen, but not in the near future. trump invited putin to come to washington and they delayed that meeting until next year until after the mueller investigation wraps up. there will be resistance in the administration to having more meetings with trump and putin. trump is the president. if he wants

cohen's actions as it may relate to him. and that is certainly significant. alex. >> kelly o'donnell. great setup. joining me now here in studio, al sharpton who had breakfast with michael cohen on friday morning and spoke with him about the situation. so with a welcome to you, i've been dieing to talk to you about this. how did this meeting come about? >> several weeks ago i was at the regency which is where a lot of the political types eat breakfast. and i ran into michael cohen who is staying there in the hotel. and i spoke to him and he spoke to me. then a couple of weeks later, he just text me. and we've known each other 20 years. in fact, any time we had a social justice fight with donald trump or when donald trump wanted to reach out to me because he wanted james brown to perform at his casino in atlantic city and i was very close with james brown. michael cohen is the guy that would reach out and we kind of knew each other for 20 years. and he text me out of nowhere and said let's get together. i want to just talk to you. >> what went through your mind? >> i didn't know what to think. i kne

for rudy giuliani and kelly touched on this, he has said nice things about michael cohen. i think in may he was saying he was an honorable lawyer, this week saying he's been lying all his life. the president this morning tweeting something he tweeted back last year about donald trump, jr. now trying to throw shade and say why is michael colon changing his mind. it kind of reminds me of how when paul manafort was brought into the campaign initially people kind of talked about him as the experience being brought up to run the trump campaign. and then once he was in the white house began getting in trouble with mueller. became clear he was no longer helpful, in fact, hurting the trump brand. and that's when sean spicer came out saying well, he's not important and we don't have anything to do with him. >> when you said truth and fact are circumstantial and you're talking about aattorneys in the white house, actually my jaw dropped because you just synopicized everything right there. congressman dan heck was in the studio and here's part of what he said. >> this is donald trump

cohen: any other questions? any other discussion? okay. thank you. >> thank you supervisor. i want to thank the committee and the board budget analyst and also kelly, for their help for preparing the budge. we're comfortable with where we are. >> supervisor cohen: all right. thank you. we're going to hear next from the planning department. >> can we please take action on the recreation and park department budget? >> supervisor cohen: take action on this budget? >> on the rec and park budget. >> supervisor cohen: i think i heard if if i'm not mistaken, help me out here that we're going to accept the b.l.a. policy recommendations. we're deleting the 250 extended cab but deny funding. >> correct. accept budget analyst recommendation for the budget. >> supervisor cohen: also accept the b.l.a.'s base recommendations. is there a second for that? seconded by supervisor sheehy. planning. >> i sent an email asking to be moved to friday. >> supervisor cohen: no problem, that it fine. we'll see you tomorrow. >> item number six is related to the planning department. >> supervisor cohen: sir, are you prepared to talk on item six? >> yes, i am. >> supervisor co

cohen: excellent. thank you. i'd like to recognize miss kelly kirkpatrick. >> good morning, committee members. kelly kirkpatrick. in reviewing the budget, both of the controller's office on the technical end, there are a myriad of errors, coding errors, project codes that need to be adjusted, one-time costs that were accidently loaded as ongoing or vice versa. we have them outlined in the letter. the attached detailed sheet that outlines each of these changes is not with the letter at this time, but it will be submitted to you this afternoon electronically, and i believe it is the advice of the city attorney that you accept these, and perhaps we can wait until wednesday once the technical sheet has been provided to you for review and perhaps some other technical adjustments will be put to you at that time, as well. >> supervisor cohen: all right. do you want to walk us through the technical adjustments around 1:00? >> i'm happy to. would you like me to receipt the bullets? >> supervisor cohen: yes, just for the public. >> collecting entries in the public trust fund, correcting position entries

cohen. >> see you at the white house in a bit, kelly. i want to bring in former u.s. attorney joyce vance. editor in chief, ben. and national political reporter for nbc news.com, jonathan allen. gang, three things i want to talk about here. number one, what this tape does and does not tell us. number two, the questions coming up next. number three, where michael cohen goes from here. let me start with the significance of this recording. what we have learned from this. there are folks who might hear it and say, no big deal. it appears donald trump knew of this arrangement to try to silence mcdoug karen mcdougal. it appears he wanted to kill that until after the election, with the use of the word "delay." and hope hicks, who was the white house communications director, knowingly or unknowingly lied about the deal in the days before the election. she was either lied to or she actively lied when she came out with that statement. joyce, to you, legally, what kind of exposure does the president have now? >> i'm not sure that this tape changes anything dramatically. it is on

. >> kelly -- kfl jane i should say, the trump team is trying to paint cohen as a liar.hey think that should help their defense. as someone who can't be trusted if that's the case, do you think there is a risk taufl in making cohen an enemy. >> well, i -- if that day is coming it might have already passed. i have to be honest i was worning if they're holding out hope because notice that donald trump that is not given michael cohen a catchy nickname. we all remember when the split with steve bannon came. donald trump tweeted and called him sloppy steve. i'm joking a little bit here but not entirely. i think that's sort of donald trump's mo and we have not seen that yet. the thing is to be honest i think they have a very good case that michael cohen is not credible. i mean if he -- if it's the case of -- if what he is saying now is true then he lied before. but at the same time michael cohen -- we have known for years that this guy is a shady character. i mean, that's one of the reasons the fbi raided his offices is they're looking into some of his shading dealings with th

. >> supervisor cohen: this year, we're asking for people to make budget allocations for $2 million. kelly kirkpatrick, if you could verify that. that's $1 million over -- $1 million for one year, correct, for last year's process? she's looking it up. she will get back to us. let's pivot to your other -- >> supervisor sheehy: sure. again, i would say that we can have that conversation one of the arguments that i was looking at is that sometimes at least the way it's been in terms of the requests that have come in, some of the different budget priorities shift given the fact that some departments that work with different organizations don't necessarily -- we don't see the same type of budget priority request, if there's been that target over two years and then a different request this year, for instance. an example would be, that we were working to fund transitional youth employment intervention work, so we worked with the department of children, youth and families on that last year. we're now pretty solid in terms of moving the conversation forward. we don't see the same level of request t

kelly kron4 (vicki) ahead at nine... the audio recording of then- presidential candidate donald trump and his lawyer michael cohen is out... what it reveals about the alleged affair with a former playboy model. (grant) plus... intense body cam video released of that deadly shooting at a trader joe's in southern california... find out what police are now saying killed the young woman... (grant) next-- three bart-homicides in five days ...and one is still on the loose... we'll show you who police are looking for... (vicki) now at 9:30... there were three bart-homicides in five days ...and while two suspects were arrested ...one man is still on the loose tonight.(grant) bart police...releasing new photos tonight of the man they say is responsible for a deadly assault at the bay fair bart station early saturday morning. as kron4's michelle kingston explains -- arrest. (mk)ed alvarez, bart police"we are definitely getting some hits and some information into our tip line."newly released surveillance photos of the man bart police say attacked 47 year old don stevens at the bay fair bart station early saturday morning.the suspec

we have cohen -- excuse me, mayor cohen, yes, she is the president of the board of supervisors. we have the kelly's husband and wife team. mohammad. all the power in the world right here in the city by the bay. but yet look over to the media, ain't no black folks there. what is going on right here? i've got 13 seconds. i wish i had enough time. i will rule out the tapes going to 205 to 215 will show all your faces. and the fillmore exhibit. don't get enough -- [buzzer] >> clerk: thank you, mr. washington. next speaker, please. >> good afternoon. my name is rob hammond, district 7 resident speaking in favor of item 78. also a senior advisor to sunrise project, we have been leading a global campaign to get the insurance company to put its money where it's mouth is on climate change. we have secured commitments from largest insurers to stop under writing coal and tar sands operations but none of those companies who made those commitments are u.s.-based. we are hoping to change that. for decades we have been warned about climate change but despite the warnings and it's costing the industry hundreds of

cohen: thank you very much. we're going to move on to the mayor's budget and hear from miss kelly kirkpatrick. >> thank for your presentation. you can begin. i have the c.f.o. for the mayor's office of housing and community development. we are in agreement with the b.l.a. policy recommendation and i am here to answer any questions you might have about the budget. >> we recommend reductions totalling $75,000 in 2018-2019. they are all one-time savings. the reductions would increase of 37.6% of the 18-19 budget. in addition, as she mentioned, it will be recommended to place on reserve and depending the results to dedicating the funding of cultural districts and also we recommend closing out prior unexpended at $154,688 which with one-time savings of $200,000 for total general funds savings and we do not recommend that with $3,100,000 on budget and finance reserve for the second year. and with the>> supervisor cohen: and i understand that supervisor f fewer has detailed questions with the office of mayor's and can you give me the exact office? this is mayor's office and it is a bit fluid. that number is dependent

cohen case. now rudy giuliani asked the judge and granted a waiver of that privilege. giuliani told kelly o'donnell he believed it was already out there so no harm done to waive the privilege. we're in the sure what's on the tape and whether it implicates anyone in criminality. three areas of exposure of danger to the president with michael cohen. one years of past real estate business dealings cohen is aware of that he's done with the president. secondly the issue of whether the discussion of the campaign surrounded these payments to the women. because if these payments were made pursuant to getting donald trump elected, they could be campaign contributions, they were not accounted as such and that could be a crime. lastly, david, mixz cohen is implicated in the dossier, information about the whole russia interference as a key player in russia collusion. he denies that. nothing implicates him. the real question is whether any of the documents sees thy putting michael cohen in the russia investigation and implicate donald trump that way. >> the timing, something simple to the way the lega

cohen. what did the president say and what did it tell us of his state of knowledge. >> to be clear kelly, you correct the record if i screw up here. this is the administration that here to for had denied even basically noiknowing the woman. >> we have heard they are not aware of any outside relationships. they denied that took place and there has been discrediting names about women who brought allegations against the president. there has been, we know nothing about the attitude from the campaign in the the white house. when questions are posed, now that he's in office, they try to put it to outside lawyers who are responsible for answering those things. the fact that it gives us a window into the president's private time in his office of people he trusts and hear some of h is comments. that's for people to assess what they think he's saying and how big it is. it takes us away from the blanket denials we heard for a long time. >> kelly o'donell starting us off. thank you. mimi rocka, handling the president's case. charlie sykes. mimi, let's start with you here. the president's attorney rudy gi

. >> kelly jane, the president is meeting with italy's prime minister and there usually a q & a session at some point. normally he will also about cohennk he is handle that? >> when he has seasoned leader by himself, he sometimes has difficulty handling it. the prime minister is a bit of an outsider like trump, himself. and so it's very hard to say how he is going to handle it. you know, he is probably going to be a little angry but i still wonder if he is holding back a bit, you know? as i was saying yesterday on the station, you know, he has not given michael cohen one of those crazy nicknames. we knew the break with steve bannon was complete when he called steve bannon sloppy steve on twitter. he has not done that yet with michael cohen. i wonder is he still hoping for something -- i'm not sure. >> it's interesting. if you don't get a nickname, there is a still of threat of hope for you? >> exactly, exactly. >> julian, i know the president was very quiet this weekend. it's possible he was still hoping the new cycle would positive on the academic figures that came out on friday. you wrote an interesting article which is to say histo

know there's been allegations general kelly is someone who leaks in the media as a way to try to change trump's behavior. i don't think that would be lost on michael cohenknows how the trump orbit works and if you look at the twitter feed he's very clearly sending smoke signals to donald trump talking talking about how he values freedom of the press. all of those things are clearly targeted at none other than donald trump. >> there are clearly provocations here from donald trump's former personal lawyer, his fixer, we always use that word. if that theory is correct, the president doesn't seem to be responding to them the way perhaps cohen hopes. >> that's because the relationship is already dead. i don't think it's smoke signals. he's facing immense legal bills, we're talking high six figures, we're talking kids he's got to put through college. he doesn't have any business. and the amount of time he's going to be spending on the mueller probe and southern district probe and the amount of money, it's going to cost a lot. same with lanny davis. i think when michael cohen when he's been attacking the president on twitter, indirectly, mind you, is really re

from kelly kirkpatrick on the rebalancing plan, and i will offer some brief remarks on the proposed spending plan that is now public. chief, welcome back to the chamber. >>> thank you. >> supervisor cohen: please give you the floor. the floor is yours. >> thank you, supervisor, thank you, board committee. i want to start out by just saying i sent to the committee some documents friday evening just based on our last session, and that included the controller's sector car patrolling staffer's analysis. supervisor sheehy had requested some copy of the cost of crime, so i ran the cost of crime calculator, and a pretty comprehensive study the ram institute did on the cost of crime. also i sent you the proposed academy class schedule, and the last slide is a breakdown of the 250 proposed additional officers that we're requesting in this budget. with that said, let me just give an overview of where we are and where we ended up on friday. as i said friday, we thank the b.l.a. for their report, and we do support and are in agreement with the 2.9 million in cuts, however, we do disagree with the policy recommendation of the b.l.a. in terms of the police staffing. we believe it's essential to cont

kelly o., a lot of different captions to that mine was just awkward. let's talk about the 2016 trump tower meeting in the month of june and the allegations that michael cohen is putting out there saying, look, donald trump, our president, then candidate, knew in advance about this meeting. >> right. >> both cohen and donald trump, jr. have testified before your committee. i know you can't confirm or deny. >> you know i can't. and won't as well. >> but what are your thoughts on this? >> so, i think the walls are closing in. i said that to you, i think, a week or so ago. this is yet another proof positive that the investigation is getting closer and closer in many regards. the fact of the matter is this is donald trump's worst nightmare, it's not just this revelation or allegation because it's yet to be corroborated but it's the fact there are 99 additional tapes into the one that was revealed this week. so, i think what is of material significa significance, here, alex, we've moved from the area to conspiracy. with the meeting hiding in plain sight when he admonished the russians to go ahead and get hillary clinton's e-mails. now with prior knowledge and in

kelly said in the opening this is all getting very confusing. there's all sorts of information flying in all sorts of information. >> that's a strategy. he had three basic themes as best i can tell. michael cohen is despicable. we don't like him anymore. number two michael cohen is unarmed. he doesn't have anything. we have got all these tapes but there's really nothing there. he's got an agenda that nobody should trust. rudy giuliani is throwing all that out. i started as a young reporter covering the courts. they are throwing out a half dozen different reasons why his client is innocent, you should really focus in on that case because there's a pretty good chance that lawyer is trying to confuse you and make you look in a lot of different directions rather than recognize there's something really serious going on here. i think lanny davis is winning because rudy giuliani is trying too hard. >> okay. draug from some deep background your front. listen more to rudy giuliani. >> we have negotiations going on with them. we have an out standing offer to them. they haven't responded in about a week to ten days. i don't hold that against them. they have a lot going on like we do. >> what does that of

cohen, your leadership and this process was something very different from year one. so thank you for all the committee members on the budget, the controller, budget legislative analyst, mayor's office and kelly kirkpatrick and her team and all the other city attorneys that advise us to walk a fine line, deputy city attorney givner being at the front of that. thank you very much. >> supervisor a. peskin: thank you, supervisors. supervisor stefani? >> supervisor c. stefani: thank you, supervisor peskin. i want to echo my colleagues gratitude for the process and the budget and finance committee. supervisor fewer, yee and sheehy and to president cohen. it was an amazingly-smooth process. and also, i have to say, it was fun at times. because president cohen is not dry when it comes to budget and finance. one would think numbers could be, but not when chair cohen is leading us through budget and finance. so i want to really thank you for the process. it was truly remarkable how smooth it went. i was a legislative aide for three years so i especially want to call out the legislative aide who helped us through because we can't do it without them and call out the public safety investments and through