. >> december 31st, 1989, kirtland, ohio.al police department receives an alarming tip from atf officials in kansas city, missouri. >> the dispatcher told me, he had the foreman who said there were five bodies buried in a barn on chardon road in kirtland. >> the sergeant heads to the abandoned property to search for any signs of a possible grave. >> we walked inside, there was a concrete floor. saw no evidence of anything suspicious. the next day is when i called the atf and asked them to talk to their informant, draw a diagram and fax it to us so we knew exactly where these bodies were located. >> the informant is a former member of the local religious group that used to reside on the farm. he draws a precise grid of the barn to show the kirtland police where the bodies are located. >> once clear and the dirt floor was exposed, you could tell the ground was very spongy, like somebody had been digging there. so we started digging that night. 9:07 p.m. we found the first body of an adult male. >> five victims are eventually ex