and katkov’s studio, looking ahead, i will say that he studied in this studio for 10 years until kotkovly ’s tendency to photographically accurately record an object in his memory and then reproduce it on paper with the same accuracy, and recognizing this, he instructed anatoly to record the corners of minsk buildings that were or were destroyed or generally already in such a state that they were destined for demolition, then, he kotkov foresaw this, or the preserved, these corners of minsk, it must be said that in the first almost 10 years after the liberation of minsk it was strictly prohibited, without special permission, photograph or record on paper in drawings the ruins of minsk. probably the authorities decided that the poor minsk residents had three years of occupation under the germans, under the nazis, that they had enough of all sorts of torment, and there was no need to torment their memory with the image of these ruins, there everything, but the vigilantes did not pay attention to the boy, the teenager, with a folder of paper, and nalivaev began to record these corners of m

conviction that this is all happening for the first time, for example, there is 1863, the polish riot, kotkov westerners on the other hand, poland is for our and your freedom, europe supports, well, it’s clear that this is the full picture, much more. time, so neatly, let's say, if not modern, it turns out that even the seventeenth year is not such an important milestone, if we remember that all this happened, does this provide an opportunity to maintain some kind of sobriety, not to unconditionally take sides, does history give academic sobriety or is it sobriety of a different kind, history gives wisdom, uh-huh, and gives an understanding that we are not exclusive today, moreover, our ancestors , and - the more i sometimes dive into the history of certain similar situations, as we have, there are a lot of them, the more i understand that our ancestors in many ways, without owning iphones and fashionable programs, were wiser than us, namely, they found simple, understandable , non-technological, human solutions in those difficult situations, and what they created was more durable, therefore.