. >> vice-president laarus? >> aye. >> and commissioner honda? >> aye. >> thank you, the vote is 5-0, the denial is overruled and the permit will issue with those conditions and findings. thank you. >> thank you. moving on then to item 5, appeal number 13-019, benny yee versus the department of public work, bureau of street use and mapping, property is multiple locations along 22nd avenue and irving street protesting the issuance on february 12, 2013 to sbc pacific bell engineering, utility excavation permit. permit number 13exc-0820 for hearing today. we will start with the appellant's agent, you have 7 minutes. >> thank you, my name is george lea, i represent benny yee, mr. yee is a small business owner and one of the owners of the affected properties. he is a well known community leader, a member of the sunset outer merchant's association and has served on the san francisco redevelopment agency in the city and county for 13 years. there are two issue that is are raised in the appeal, one is one of notice and one is one of -- as to the merits o