let's go live to frankfurt to chelsea to lanie josie alledge a surprise is this used up new doesn't it. it's certainly a surprise and certainly relief given all of the really gloomy data that's been coming out of germany over the past several months looking into the room to the details of the report sort of the hardest hit areas of german of the german economy seem to have rebounded so trade to the u.k. was a lot higher trade to the u.s. was a lot higher there was a continued decline in exports to china but i think seeing the increases in exports to china or to the u.s. and the u.k. was definitely a bright spot also there was an increase in exports to be to the end that auto sector as well which has been hit very hard over the past several months i think now there's that potential that germany could actually avoid a technical recession because of how strong this data was there had been a pretty much consensus here that germany was going to fall into recession after seeing growth the kind of the 2nd quarter looks like they may actually be able to avoid that now just use noise to finish