here to circumstance's state of the -- to assess state of the the obama economy ar artur lapre. it is february of 2001, it sounds great, is it? >> no, it is not. but let me say that from nashville, we are very proud of your record, a nashvilleian he here. i am so proud you retained your tennessee accent. but if you look at these numbers, the gdp number, 4 1/2 off trillion, you look at employment. only increase is. am we had is population increases, you know number of people employed sheriff population. fell to trough after a great recession, and 5 1/2 years, if you look at new housing sales, it is just not going anywhere, it is a bad economy. the wages are lower, and it is obama's economy, it was precipitateeed i believe by george w. bush but obama has owned it, he has been here for a long time, what he has done, has not made it better. ashley: you mention wage growth. 72% of the economy based on consumer spending, wages down 23%. that is significant. >> ouch. that really hurts, you see is the just, pervasive in every aspect of the economy, you know, i don't -- i am not surprise