tonight barbara on wine and president and executive director of the lawyers committee for civil rights under law hilary shelton washington bureau director and senior vice president for advocacy at the end he and katherine. cullison gonzalez senior attorney and director of voter protection at the advancement project let's get back to it. to the three of you are attorneys and i'm i'm just curious the the constitution mentions the phrase right to vote several times and it's been amended with the phrase right to vote several times but it's always been in in very near. people should not be denied the right to vote based on race people should not be denied the vote right to vote based on gender it. is there in my misreading that is there no explicit federal right to vote does anybody or should there be katherine well there definitely should be there isn't an explicit right to vote in a numerated right to vote in our constitution and we're one of the few countries that doesn't have you know iran doesn't have. and we don't south africa has a numerated right to vote in so it's an explicit fundamental right and since bush v gore m