commissioner lazarus any public comment on the minutes. >> seeing none, then on that motion from commissioner lazarus commissioner fung commissioner president honda commissioner swig 0 e thank you that item passes with a vote of 4 to zero commissioner wilson absent we'll take our item 5 appeal carmen versus the zoning administrator on richardson avenue protest protesting the issuance of a rear yard variance constrict a 3 floor and roof deck for the rear yard of a single-family dwelling and we'll start with the appellant. >> good evening and welcome. >> i guess you didn't release i ordered a private hearing this evening. >> yes. this is so rare actually. >> i feel like i'm at the end of the >> welcome reuben, junius & rose i need to make a disclosure. i wish to disclose i've hired reuben, julius & rose on a on a project of my own the handling the board will not have an effect on my decision. this evening. >> thank you, commissioners ryan patterson on behalf of the appellant an appeal to construct a third floor on top of a 2 story in the marina my client owns the adjacent property directly to the north at the 2547 to 49 cellist nut street and

commissioner lazarus any public comment on the minutes. >> seeing none, then on that motion from commissioner lazarus commissioner fung commissioner presidentonda commissioner swig 0 e thank you that item passes with a vote of 4 to zero commissioner wilson absent we'll take our item 5 appeal carmen versus the zoning administrator on richardson avenue protest protesting the issuance of a rear yard variance constrict a 3 floor and roof deck for the rear yard of a single-family dwelling and we'll start with the appellant. >> good evening and welcome. >> i guess you didn't release i ordered a private hearing this evening. >> yes. this is so rare actually. >> i feel like i'm at the end of the >> welcome reuben, junius & rose i need to make a disclosure. i wish to disclose i've hired reuben, julius & rose on a on a project of my own the handling the board will not have an effect on my decision. this evening. >> thank you, commissioners ryan patterson on behalf of the appellant an appeal to construct a third floor on top of a 2 story in the marina my client owns the adjacent property directly to the north at the 2547 to 49 cellist nut street and o

commissioner lazarus any public comment on the minutes. >> seeing none, then on that motion from commissioner lazarus commissioner fung commissioner presidentioner swig 0 e thank you that item passes with a vote of 4 to zero commissioner wilson absent we'll take our item 5 appeal carmen versus the zoning administrator on richardson avenue protest protesting the issuance of a rear yard variance constrict a 3 floor and roof deck for the rear yard of a single-family dwelling and we'll start with the appellant. >> good evening and welcome. >> i guess you didn't release i ordered a private hearing this evening. >> yes. this is so rare actually. >> i feel like i'm at the end of the >> welcome reuben, junius & rose i need to make a disclosure. i wish to disclose i've hired reuben, julius & rose on a on a project of my own the handling the board will not have an effect on my decision. this evening. >> thank you, commissioners ryan patterson on behalf of the appellant an appeal to construct a third floor on top of a 2 story in the marina my client owns the adjacent property directly to the north at the 2547 to 49 cellist nut street and owns the rent

any public comment on the minutes seeing none, there is a motion by commissioner lazarus to adopt the minutes of october commissioner fung commissioner president honda commissioner wilson and commissioner swig okay. thank you that that motion carries with the vote of 5 to zero and moving on to item 4 appeal 16 dash 128 marilyn versus the zoning administrator on pacific avenue protesting the issuance to john david i didn't and fiona to construct a two-story horizontal addition on the rear of a single-family dwelling that will be entirely within the rear yard public hearing for this was held on september 2016 and the board continued it tattoo allow the parties on opportunity discuss we'll hear back with the president consent and give the parties 2 minutes with the result of their efforts starting with the appellant reuben, julius & rose on a reuben, junius & rose representation as an entity before the board will not have an effect on my decision. today. >> and commissioner wilson i know you were absent have you had an opportunity to review the video and - okay. great hear from the appellant 3 minutes. >> good evening, comm