liam holden was as you say in 1972. his confession had been extracted from him by means of torture, and as you say, his conviction was quashed a decade ago, he was awarded one million pounds in damages there, the maximum limit but he took a civil case against the ministry of defence and it is that case which has delivered itsjudgment and it is that case which has delivered its judgment today. and it is that case which has delivered itsjudgment today. what did thejudge say? delivered its judgment today. what did the judge say?— did the 'udge say? well, i should oint did the judge say? well, i should oint out did the judge say? well, i should point out that — did the judge say? well, i should point out that liam _ did the judge say? well, i should point out that liam holden, - did the judge say? well, i should point out that liam holden, why| did the judge say? well, i should i point out that liam holden, why he gave evidence to the hearing which took place last year, he died last september, he was not therefore in court