lilian greenwood was labour's shadow transport secretary.sport select committee. it scrutinises the work of chris grayling's department. lilian greenwood, welcome to the daily —— the bbc muzak five. this was not a surprise although the company saying they are surprised and disappointed by —— the bbc news at five. is the third failure in the space of ten years on the east coast main line. we want to look at previous failures and why the secretary of state has made the decisions he has. also we want to look at these plans for a future public private partnership, because to be honest there is little evidence that vertical arrangement will deliver, and on this line where there is a multitude of operators seems a very strange place to try it out. is there something specific about this franchise, you think, that makes it so hard to predict likely revenue and therefore result in companies over bidding and finding themselves in a mess?|j think finding themselves in a mess?” think that is one of the questions we will be looking at in our inquiry. 0bv