i would like to thank our deputy city attorney lisa cabrera who has patiently read every version and en proposed language up to and including suggesting the oral amendment that i'll be making today. the deputy city attorney has been helpful and i'm grateful for that assistance. i would like to thank the chief this is obviously a resolution that is one of ambiguous dis approval and i'm glad the chief was able to focus on the outcomes and we're able to work and reach a consent on agreement. just like president elias is the most important thing is that we're moving forward. i would like to thank my colleagues and fellow commissioners but vice president carter-oberstone for raising thish with the seriousness that it deserves and with a clarity and certainly that is admirable and providing the base of the this resolution is based on, so i'm glad that vice president raised this. and i'm happy for president elias for bringing this back today, i think it's important that we pass this resolution and that we get it right and i thank president elias for bringing it back so we can get it back. s