liz kendall, the shadow pensions and work secretary, will be coming on.elegraph, suggesting that the first private school has already closed down in anticipation of labour scrapping that vat break for private schools. i suppose the question for miss kendall is, is labour now advocating a policy that results in schools being shut down? >> well, i guess i mean, they don't believe in private education, do they? so they won't be that sad about it . so won't be that sad about it. so the question is, is whether is that policy is actually forced. it upon them? >> well, of course the big issue, the big issue is if schools close down or if people stop sending their children to private school in any great numbers, what does that do to the revenue take that their basing a whole load of their policies on? >> also, stephen, where do we put these children? so the ifs, the institute for fiscal studies has predicted that at worst , has predicted that at worst, this policy could result in 40,000 for private school pupils with their parents not able to pay with their paren