firstly, as you said to louise ellman, words _ it?llman, words to have contact l it? firstly, as you said to louise i ellman, words to have contact and they mean different the context he said it in is very clearly a call for, quote, peaceful liberty between israelis and palestinians. to read it another way is absurd. let me push back on saying to the river to the sea, palestine will be free, is in any way controversial, because it is not. the palestinians between there are dispossessed so it is a call for justice, and doesn't mean a reversal of the current situation. living under apartheid, now being bombed and having war crimes committed against them, it will be israelis. it means all people living together, as andy mcdonald said, in peaceful liberty. what you think the impact of removing the rip will be? i5 removing the rip will be? i3 ludicrous. you endorse war crimes and you are fine in the labour party. and you are fine in the labour pa . ;, , and you are fine in the labour pa . . , . , , party. that is a very big accusation. _ p