in the garden luzhin you're asserting that a supernatural career doesn't exist and that belief in a personal god qualifies as at the reason you also make that argument for the belief in any sort of consciousness be armed individual for example could it be that the universe itself is a conscious organism and works one expression of it within it or for that matter what is conscious as. well i don't know what consciousness is and that's a very difficult philosophical question i don't think it's probably going to be helpful to talk about the universe as a whole being conscious i know that some rather mystical philosophers that just did something like that i think that whatever consciousness is it's manifested by brains is something to do with brains are all the functional equivalent of brains i don't i wouldn't rule out that one day somebody might build an electronic computer which was programmed in such a way that that it was conscious that seems to me to be actually quite likely. but it comes from very very complex organization such as the brain which is an extremely complicated organization o