us, but ayas shabuddinov is with us, because he was literally everywhere, well, at bonya’s, at lyubyatenka’sthe boy shabbudinov. one of those who were not afraid. to publicly speak out in defense of ayaz shabuddinov, this is the commissioner under the president of russia for the protection of the rights of entrepreneurs, boris titov. his the position is voiced by the deputy head of the expert legal center of the ombudsman, natalya ryabova. now, after there have become widespread students who, on the contrary, write that this is very useful, very important, very significant, moreover, as far as i know, in the appeal, when the consideration was considered in the appeal. as he put it, the pain points of this case are, firstly, the criminalization of relations within the framework of a service agreement. in addition, the blogger was given an obviously excessive measure of restraint; the investigation declaratively determined that educational the like center’s programs did not help entrepreneurial activity and high income generation, the ombudsman believes. first, this should be the opinion of ex