in april , lyudmila, the judge of the northern commercial court of appeal, resigned garnyk she was one of the first judges to take the initial qualification assessment and failed. in 2016, the judge was unable to confirm her professional knowledge and ability to administer justice. the qualification commission sent her to the national school of judges for retraining. even then, the members of the commission had a lot of questions about garnyk's fortune. in 2014, 3 million hryvnias appeared in the judge's accounts. she was never able to explain their origin. at first she said that it was from the sale of an apartment, but it turned out that it was her apartment sold a year later. at the next qualifying assessment, the version changed. everything is very transparent, everything is very simple. i worked for 20 years. further, even more, i worked as a lawyer in odesa, my son also worked as a lawyer after graduating from the academy and after coming to kyiv also worked as a lawyer, i also worked in a women's colony, i already have 40 years of experience, both as a lawyer and a leading lawye

lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away, in an elite coastal village. sovin in odesa, her income - that was only wages. we filmed and posted this house as it looks, there is a really nice estate near mine. after moving to kyiv, harnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had considerable savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized the office apartment. i received the same apartment on chervonozorin, as a judge, from the state, and then you privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. we we will not even comment on it, we suggest you just listen. arrived, a very interesting thought. and why did i write a scientific article, if there is a decision that has gained legal force, then it is a precedential decision. you are a candidate of sciences, so you are a 10th year student, americans, they are more , pitiful towards their own, farmers , their own, here are such singles, there everything is aimed at helping this person,

lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesa.salary . we filmed and published this house as it looks. really chic estate near mine, with moving to kyiv, garnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had more or less savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an office apartment more than 100 km away. i received the same apartment on chervonozoryny, as a judge, and you later privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, in the course of qualification evaluation. she shares her thoughts, we won't even comment on it, we suggest you just listen, she came to a very interesting thought, why did i write a scientific article, if any a decision that has entered legal force is an effective decision, you are a candidate of sciences, yes, in the 10th year. americans, they are more pitiful to their own, farmers to their own, these are lonely people, everything is aimed at helping this person to somehow get out of this situation. in 2016, the qualification commission rec

lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesa. it was income only wages. we filmed and published this house as it looks, it is really chic. an estate near mine with the move to kyiv, garnyk, who, judging by the declaration, had more or less savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an office apartment more than 100 km away. i got the same apartment on chervonezoryn, as a judge, and you later privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification evaluation, she shares her thoughts, we are it we will not even comment, we suggest you just listen, i came to a very interesting opinion, why i wrote a scientific article, if there is a decision that has gained legal force, then it is a final decision, you are a candidate of sciences, so you will pass the 10th year, they are more they are pitiful towards their farmers, towards their lonely ones, everything is aimed at helping this person, somehow this is the best way out of the situation. in 2016, the qualifi

the position of a judge prohibits working for part time lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesa, her income was only a salary. we filmed and posted this house as it looks, there is a really nice estate near mine. after moving to kyiv, garnyk, who, judging by the declaration... had considerable savings, did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an office apartment more than 100 km away. i got the same apartment on chervonozorny, as a judge, you later privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. we will not even comment on it. we suggest you just listen, i came to a very interesting thought, and why did i write a scientific article, if there is a decision that has gained legal force, then it is an editorial decision, you are a candidate of sciences, so since the 10th year, americans, they are more, it is a pity . relate to their farmers, to their own, here are these singles, there everything is

lyudmila garnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away, in the elite coastal village of sauvignon in odesaly a salary, we rented and published this house , how it looks, there is a really chic estate near mine, with a move to kyiv, a beautiful woman who, judging by the declaration, had more or less savings, spending them on housing in the capital is not became, simply privatized an office apartment for more than 100 km. i got the same apartment on chervonozorny, as a judge, and you later privatized it, privatized it, and we still use it. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. we will not even comment on it, we suggest you just listen. i came to a very interesting thought, why i wrote a scientific one. this, if there is a decision that has gained legal force, then this is an official decision, you are a candidate of sciences , yes, in the 10th year, americans, they are more, pitiful to their own, farmers, to their own, here are these singles, everything is aimed there to... help this person, as it were, to get out of this situa

, and a lawyer, and a leading lawyer in odessa, which means a leading, good lawyer, note that lyudmila garnykorked as a judge since 2002, which means that in 2014 she simply could not earn millions while performing the work of a lawyer, the position of a judge prohibits working part-time. lyudmila harnyk has a luxurious house 335 km away, in the summer coastal village of sauvignon in odesa. her income was just a salary . we filmed and posted this house as it looks, there is a really nice estate near mine. with the move to kyiv, harnykyak. judging by the declaration, she had considerable savings, she did not spend them on housing in the capital, simply privatized an office apartment for more than 100 km. the same apartment, that is. as a judge, i received the state as a judge, and then you privatized it, privatized it, and we use it that way too. lyudmila harnyk is a candidate of sciences, during the qualification assessment, she shares her thoughts. we will not even comment on it, we suggest you just listen. i came to a very interesting thought, why i wrote a scientific article, if there is a

from 2016 to 2020, lyudmila garnyk simply received salary, without doing justice, and because she still could not pass the qualification assessment. as a result, she still passed it, her fortune did not decrease. judge ludmila harnyk left. retired on april 27 , 2023, retained the title of judge and at the expense of taxpayers, that is, you and i will receive a lifetime allowance from the state in the amount of 50 to 100% of her judicial salary. and this is the judge of the shevchenkiv district court of the city of kyiv, lidia shchebunyaeva. she resigned on april 25 of this year. the maid of cafemida is known for. that released from the imprisonment of oleksandr medvyd, accused of kidnapping and torturing activists of the revolution of dignity, ihor lutsenko and yuri verbytskyi. the latter was brutally killed. on january 22, 2014, verbytskyi's body was found in the forest 500 m from the hnidyn petrivske road. the investigation established that oleksandr medvid personally participated in the abduction of activists from oleksandrivska. hospital, after which they were transported to the sub