well there isn't a clear fault line between the states and mackel but one thing is for sure gone are the days where angela merkel felt that she simply couldn't knock heads together couldn't get all states to follow the guidance of scientists who had been calling for a much tighter lock down months ago and that was when some states simply weren't having it now the dynamic has completely changed germany is completely in the red if you look at them are way beyond that magic formula of 50 infections per 100000 people within the space of 7 days which is seen as manageable it now is somewhere between $77.00 and upwards of 200 and that is something clearly where the alarm bells are being heard very loudly and we do expect to see a much higher common denominator when it comes to what the baseline of action needed right now is alarm bells are ringing very loud because the infection rates are so high as you said where is the government strategy until now gone wrong. well that's the thing there was a certain element of disunity i think things something that was a strength in the past the german