much.heather: a retired police officer in portugal has now on a libel appeal against the parents of madeleine mccannyears old in 2007 when she disappeared while on vacation with her parents in portugal. the now retired police officer led the search for that toddler and later he wrote a book about it. the mccanns sued him following criticism of them in his book. he had claimed that they were somehow involved in their daughter's kidnapping. this new verdict means the officer's book can be sold again. for more on this let's bring in keisha heaven, a criminal defense attorney and richard st. paul, a former prosecutor and criminal defense attorney. this story continues to be so heartbreaking for the family, certainly but i want to ask you about this trial judge. there was an initial trial judge who sided with the parents, saying they had been the famed in the book. the book was removed from the shelves but a new court has overturned that ruling. keisha, why? >> i disagree with the division in this case because in order to for a plaintiff to prove that someone was guilty of libel, they have to prove one,