please welcome suzette malveaux. [applause] >> thank you how much for having me here. i'm going to address one of the issues that is squarely before the supreme court. it is little technical so bear with me but it is very important. and the question here is whether or not the plaintiffs in walmart can seek monetary relief under this particular class-action rule and if they can, under what circumstances can they seek that monetary relief and then let it back and think about why is that important to employment discrimination cases? first of all, as was mentioned before rule 23 is what we are looking at. rule 23 t. two in particular but it is appropriate if you have it defendant that acts in a way that is broadly applicable to most people in the class, then it is appropriate to have a class-action, and they are seeking an injunction or maybe a declaration. so for example if everybody is challenging the same general practice, the same sort of systemic conduct in the workplace, everybody pretty much shares the same goal. if we share that same goal, then we are united in and

is that the solution to be actually needed competitive malveaux with parents in charge of teachers? >> guest: you need parents more involved and the question becomes what can we do to make the government and parents more involved to make sure this doesn't happen. i'm not too sure about whether it is boiling down to this idea of more choice or less choice because if you look at the education performance across europe, they are seeing a backslide certainly on the oecd standards to the rest of the world. if it were about twice you wouldn't have expected them to be with the united states sliding down. one of the things i do talk about in my work that possibly something worth thinking about is the idea of the transitional and very popular in mexico and brazil and being rolled out of the pilot program by mayor bloomberg is to do the right thing so your child goes to school 98% of the time and to get $100, you get immunized, immunized for a disease you get $100. now there's this discussion in europe whether or not people should start getting paid for their children's to be cut children to