i was going to mention that untimely passing of mary gallagher. e was at one time, for a short period, zoning administrator for the city and the department. so, mary has a long history of working with us and the community. so, we were fairly surprised and saddened by her passing as well. the second announcement i had was, is good news. you may recall that going back to 2005 or 6 there has been an ongoing series of litigation and lawsuits against the city on the housing element. it goes back to the 2004 housing element. you recall there was a court decision at that time that required the city to conduct a full blown e.i.r., unprecedented at the time, the first city in the state, and the city because of the timing did e.i.r. on the 2004 and 2009 elements, that is just resolved in the court of appeals and found completely in the city's favor. so, we are very, very pleased about that. it has been a long time coming. i wanted to do a shout out if i might for the key attorneys in the city attorney's office on this. audr audrey pearson have been involved