your host, melinda crane. melinda: hello and welcome to "quadriga." is the rhetoric of war suitable and useful or counterproductive? that is one of the questions we want to talk about today on "quadriga" with three people who are following the incidents in france and their aftermath very closely. it is a pleasure to welcome ulrike guerot. she is a political analyst and the founder and director of the think tank european democracy lab. she lived for many years in paris and has family there. she says the decisive question is do we defend our values or our security. and very glad to have asiem el difraoui on the show. he is a german /egyptian expert on islamism. who is working with the can dade -- candid think tank based here in berlin. he is currently living in france, and he says the fight against i.s. cannot be fought solely with military resources. and finally, great to have alan posener back on the show. he is a british-born commentator for the british newspaper "die welt." he says of course it is war and it has been since the fatwa issued against s