it's melinda shara, i'm serious senior political analyst. thank you for that. well, let's hear from audiences. he is an international law professor at queens university and canada, who's previously worked in gaza for and run through an agency for palestinian refugees. he says that according to the un charter, as well as not according to the right to self defense, infant coupon territory. there is a claim that is being bandied about in the media and by political leaders. leadership especially in the west that israel enjoys a right to self defense under article $51.00 of the united nations charter in relation to the attack that was brought against it on the 7th of october by palestinian paramilitaries. that is false. i would direct all of your re, your listeners to paragraph 139139 of the international court of justice's advisory opinion on the gallon. he's a wall dated 2004. and in that paragraph, the court makes it very clear that israel does not enjoy a right of self defense under article $51.00 of the un charter in relation to a tax that emanate from we in an