after two weeks of testimony and arguments in the case of the commonwealth of kentucky versus melvin henry ignatowhe case. would they send mel ignatow to prison for the murder of his fiancee, brenda schaefer? four jurors agreed to speak with us about their deliberations. >> i believe we all feel in our hearts he was guilty. >> but they say they were bothered by the lack of physical evidence against ignatow. >> i have to have one hair, one blood sample, one anything. >> as for the eyewitness, maryann shore, they had trouble believing her. >> she didn't shed one tear. she didn't -- she was cracking smiles. how can you tell such a horrid story and sit on a witness stand cracking smiles? there's no way. >> so, then you start questioning, was she just involved or was she the one who did it all? >> and that tape, the one prosecutors felt so sure would win them a conviction? jurors thought it was very suspicious that neither shore nor ignatow ever got specific about what they were talking about. >> we played that tape probably 15 to 20 times, searching for the word grave. we did not hear that. >> out in