. >> my name is michael hurly the new water resources manager let me start by clarifying commissioner moran's question the comments today are related to the rebate and there's a separate letter and response from the puc staff regarding the 10-year but again today's comments are focussed specifically on the rebate. so to give you -- with only 1 year passing since the last major rebate the commissioner is considering modification of the budget and schedule. >> the statement you have available i made a few more copies available to the secretary. >> you are going to read this out loud. >> any objection to that that will be the order you can finish the rest of your time though. >> appreciate. do want to reiterate appreciate the staff's cooperation and support on this on the 10-year response as well as working with mr. wade and his staff on the rebate signing as well. >> thank you very much. >> happy earth day commissioner torres. >> thank you very much i have a question so there's a set of recommendations that have been presented and i'm just wondering if the puc staff general manager's of