>>commissioner michael j. antonini: any reason for the request? >> there was a noticing issue. >> okay. thank you. >> commissioners on that motion to continue all items as proposed commissioner antonini? hillis, moore, sugaya, wu, commission president fong. that motion passes unanimously 7-0 and places you under your consent calendar. all matters listed here on the consent calendar are considered to be route routine by the planning commission unless the members of the public or staff pull on request. they maybe considered as a separate item. item 4. item 4: 2013.1688q t. chang; 4155 575-91977 47-49 noe street - the east side of noe street between duboce street and 14th street on assessor's block 3538, lot 043 - request for condominium conversion subdivision to convert a three-story, six-unit building within a rto residential, transit-oriented neighborhoodd zoning district, 40-x height and bulk district. this action constitutes the approval action for the project for the purposes of ceqa, pursuant to section 31.044hh of

>>commissioner michael j. antonini: i would move. commissioner dr. roscoe m. moore jr: i second the motion. >> i'm okay with the motion with the last four or five. city clerk: your motion would be amended from the original to modify the conditions as proposed originally into the record by staff. >>commissioner michael j. antonini: it would be the original conditions and the added ones. city clerk: is that acceptable? >> yes. >> thank you. >> i was going to say that i'm in agreement with that and in agreement with the zoning administrator to not address the windows issue because it's difficult for enforcement. >> commissioner moore? >> i think it's the window relative to the type of expansion. since the applicant seems to have a good relationship with the neighborhood association, i would have them work together in the future to retain the good relationship and the window issue would solve itself. i can see in the middle of the day particular lau e when the cable car is operating alongside, there is quite a bit of activity on the street. when you open the windo

>>commissioner michael j. antonini: i think this is a very good project. a couple reasons why i like it. the specific reference to minimal glazing is really refreshing after every building we approve is all windows. it helps it to blend in with the neighborhood if it's more historic even though it has a more contemporary design with more glazing when the building an appears to fit in with the building because of that fact. also the fact that it's providing 4, three bedroom units. decent amount where you can have a family with children. you have a little bit of space here. i think it's a good idea. on the issue of one speaker, i think those in the province of dbi. it would be necessary that as approvals are made that dbi would have to ensure that any kind of rainfall is diverted away from danieling -- damaging any of the properties. it's a pretty steep hill. neighborhood support from the castro eureka valley and makes total sense to me. i'm very much in support. i would move to approve at this point. >> was that a motion? >> that was a motion. yeah. >> i wi

>>commissioner michael j. antonini: move to approve. >vice-president cindy wu: commissioner sugaya? >>commissioner hisashi sugaya: all the companies have a little bit of different technology in the types of antenna they use whether it's an lte or other stuff. and so with respect to at&t their antennas don't project as far as people may think they would. even in a straight line, i don't think they cover as the representative from at&t has said more than about 4 blocks or five 5 blocks at the most. and if you have terrain and they are directional and some of these are directed in certain directions and certain directions, well, anyway. they can be directed in certain ways. so even though there might be three close to each other, it's likely in this case given the data that we have that this site is projecting out into a different space than the other two. >> commissioners there is a motion and second to approve with conditions. on that motion, commissioner antonini, border, hillis, moore, sugaya, fong and wu. that passes unanimously 7 -0. and places you on your final agenda item 19. i

>>commissioner michael j. antonini: i think this is a good project and think the office in this area should be a future home quite a bit because of the fourth street quarter which we are now studying and this is between 4 and 5th and the rail yard which is a little further away and because it has all the benefits of being close to transportation and answers some of the issues that we are a fronted with where we are so close whe people can get to places very sy by public transit it makes a lot of sense to me and they are contributing some development fees and also i think it's a good proct and i would move to approve. >> second. >> commissier borden? can you address this? >> as an impact e we are required to do a nexus study and increase by a project. if there is use that has a certain level of impact we have to subtract that from the impact that are being created. they are already represented on the site. that's why there is a reduction based on the reduction. you are paying the net increase on impact which is what is

>>commissioner michael j. antonini: i also support it and i'm impressed by the design because while it has great features, a little more glazing and a lot of things that hark into the houses in the neighborhood particularly further down the hill and that's something we need to see more of when the newer homes are built. it blends nicely. all the things that have been said. it steps down the hill and makes it very well with the house and in fact we are getting a four bedroom home which will be very good family housing and the one next to it is not before it but it will be two houses when it's completed and they are complimentary. this has been pointed out, it does not meet affordability value of $1.5 million and probably it would be another $1.5 million in that existing house. i'm very supportive of this project and a lot of people were in favor and they did lots of outreach and so it's a good project. >> commissioners, there is a motion and second on the floor to not take dr and approve the project as proposed. commiss