from local 21, as well as seiu 1021 here today should have you any questions, as well as miss micky callahan from the department of human resources to avail herself to questions. so mr. chair, i would like to turn it back to you and see if there is any discussion. if not, we can go to public comment? >> supervisor tang, do you have? some comments . thank you, supervisor cohen, i know it's been difficult for the employees faced in this position. i know there were questions on page 5 this was language inserted and just wanted to confirm that charter amendment says, "shall not expand or contract the groups of employs eligible for retirees." >> it should be 2009. >> 2009. >> yes, it should be 2009. >> 2009, okay, that is on page 6. so my version says 2008. so i just wanted to make sure that is correct. >> okay. let's see. page 6. >> what line are you on? >> line 2, page 6. >> it says 2008. >> i don't know if we can get clarification, perhaps from the city attorney. >> deputy city attorney john givner. >> supervisor tang, do you have other comments? >> sure, my second question has to do with the