. >> ed miller banmilliband. >> i hope we can more constructively, even on afghanistan. can i start by joining him in paying tribute to the troops who have died in afghanistan. each of them shared the highest dedication, commitment, and bravery. we honor their memory and offered the consultants -- deep condolences to the families. london nor grow died doing a simple job, try to make the lives of the people of afghanistan better, a necessary part of any political settlement. she, too, showed immense bravery. we support the decision of the foreign secretary. the responsibility for her death lies solely and squarely on those who took her hostage. can i ask you to update your phone call with the president obama on the circumstances surrounding her death and the progress and to the inquiry? >> i'm grateful for the right hon. gentlemen and the way he says it. is about our troops and the tragic case of linda norgrove. i spoke with president obama that if it is extremely important. this is a joint investigation. i cannot give details about what happened that night. the " -- the