was conducted in october of last year and a request for discretionary review was filed by the miller mick kinss to the north and cynthia smith to the south. since the packet ways sent to the commission we've received an additional e-mail from christen this would be in support of dr request and i believe this e-mail was sent to each of the commissioners within did last couple of days. i'll pass this. the concerns raised in the dr request include the following. loss of light and shadowing to neighborhoods property and loss of mid plain clothes open space and visual openness and the fact it is out of schedule and characterly out of scale. the vice president reviewed it and determined the project meets the standards of residential guidelines in that the light loss and additional shadowing are within reasonable exception of the development impacts and the proposed you you are talking about e debt has minimal effects on the block spates. in conclusion the department finds is to be inconsistent with within the guidelines and didn't create extraordinary circumstances we ask for your approval that concl