mitchell taylor, thank you so much. let's take it to the panel. patrice, you just heard the bishop and the debate about corporate welfare, and the conservatives are aligning with alexandria ocasio-cortez. >> i think alexandria makes some interesting points about corporate welfare. the idea that a targeted tax greek one company encourages an environment where you have jockeying by one company with the the you spngs of zoning laws that don't get to go to other businesses. let's not forget, the taxpayers will be on the hook. i thought i saw $48,000 per taxpayer in new york for these generous tax benefits. i'm tall for insuring companies can set up shops in places like new york city. liz: is this a big fat down payment for future economic growth and jobs? >> at first glance it looks that way. i saw the graphic you put on the screen. and look there will be is a reason why governors are successful creating jobs in their state and people look to them because unlike members of congress they have to create jobs in their state as opposed to opine in ivory t