phone $25.00 with a minimum total payout of $310000000.00 so joining us now to discuss these cases molly burrows contributor with america's lawyer molly i see the story my head was exploding with how ridiculously low the settlement is $25.00 for i phone is virtually nothing there's really no indication here of how much money apple made with this practice do we know how much they were making we're probably talking about billions right. oh absolutely now i don't have any numbers that relates specifically to purchases that were made as a result of using that software that basically slowed down on their phones but apple's quarterly revenue at the end of 2017 the beginning of 2018 was $88300000000.00 band it was an all time record apple said so now then the 2 are connected but the company did credit that growth to the highest revenue ever from its new i phone line at the i phone x.l. it does look as though they made a big chunk of money although i phone sales still huge still in the 30 something billions they've slowed over the past couple years now how did apple doing this what are they doing this v