english should be supporting him and mr. mccoy does a court i'm not asking and not asking you to there was a dispute about whether mr. english was investigating about investigating his alibi defense whether there was a subsequent hearing that was tested but this is a flat out a case in which the judge was told as soon as this issues arose twice on the record that i believe i have an ethical duty to save my clients life and the client telling the judge i do not want my lawyer admitting that i am guilty. that is structural error. number two, justice breyer, this was absolutely and and mission of the guilt on the charged crime. it was at opening and closing and mr. english got up and said i am telling you, he is guilty of second-degree murder and he should spend the rest of his life in prison and under louisiana law the jury was required to be given the choice the following choices which it was murder one, murder to, manslaughter, not guilty and there is no disputing the record that murder one, murder to an manslaughter all have exac