mr. arbuthnot. >> after the chinook crash on the mull of kintyre, every during has found it impossible to attribute negligence to the pilots who died in the crash. may i thank the government for honoring the pledge made before the election to hold a review and ask our the independence of that review will be assured. >> deputy prime minister? >> i am acutely aware of his considerable expertise on defense matters and his longstanding interest in this tragic disaster and the circumstances around it. tragic disaster of circumstances surrounding it. and i'm pleased to be able to confirm today that we will be holding an independent review of the evidence on that disaster and i hope to review will be welcomed by the families of those who died in this tragic accident to ensure its complete independence, the review will become -- conducted by a respected lawyer and who is not present expressed the view on the disaster. the review and the precise will be announced soon. >> mr. braley campbell? >> last month they released a report on the bombing in 1972 were nine innocent people were murdered. the o