mr. a barker, the ceo of qatar airways and whether or not he thinks this is fair, he is very clear that he was to see the report released and has other opinions. >> i do not have that insight into the report, i would like to have insight into that report so that we have the opportunity to defend all the slander that it may contain. if you accuse somebody you could also give him the details so we can defend ourselves. >> slander is a strong word from you. we know the charge that subsidies aren't fair. >> exactly, i think mr. anderson doesn't know the difference between subsidy which he was receiving directly or through chapter 11, and equity that my government put into the airline for us as a business. hans: we asked delta to respond to that charge and we have not heard back from them will we do know is the u.s. carriers plan to make this report public later today and on top of that they are not only lobbying the administration in terms of the secretary of commerce they're meeting with u.s. lawmakers and want them reconsider the open skies initiative in the state which allows all carriers t