mr. bernier and what mr. have a plan for the future economy if you're not building a plan that protects the environment and fight climate change. that's where both of your wrong.ely >> you have been saying a lot of great things on the stage today but the problem is you made it sound like you wereth going to make climate of big party but he did did allou these things. he bought a pipeline he subsidize oil and gas in the continue accept the biggest polluters for what you to take for canadians to believe that you will follow through on your promises and what's it going to take because your words aren't good enough anymore. >> we are three-quarters the way to achieve achieving a 2030 target and we are going to surpass them. mr. singh you may be surprised to discover your plan is to build a massive refinery in alberta and the only way to do that is with federal subsidies because there is no private business for peter plan to build a refinery in alberta is worse than building a pipeline. >> mr. singh? >> we would i

mr. bernier, and it is now the opportunity of mr. scheer to debate mr. ernier on the question of leadership. >> you're right. our canada yen values. between men and women. >> you're right. >> we want people to come and share our canadian values. equality before the law. >> you have changed -- you have changed from someone who used to believe, who used to believe in immigration -- >> let mr. scheer have the question. >> who used to believe in an immigration system that was fair, orderly and compassionate and now you are making your policy based on trying to get likes and retweets in the darkest parts of twitter. we can be a country that celebrates the contribution all around the world. it's important -- >> i don't want to celebrate. >> you can do that. you can do that. >> celebrate who we are and we're not doing that. >> that is the difference between mr. bernier and myself on this issue. we believe, we believe in making canada stronger by welcoming people, adding it to our country and celebrating the things that has made us great as a hags. >> now we'll h

mr. bernier, your opportunity to respond. >> thank you.e're the people's party and we put canada first. he other leaders on the stage are globalists. they send your money to buy a u.n. security council, and also, they are giving your money to other fight climate change in asia, and in africa. u.n. is a dysfunctional be nization, and we must able to fight for our country. only party 're the that will have foreign policies that's based on our security and prosperity for our country. >> mr. bernier, thank you. he next opportunity for mr. singh to respond. >> thank you very much. thank you very much for your question, reagan. i know it's tough to ask questions in front of a big crowd. thanks for doing that and thanks and taking oining part in this discussion. to me leadership is about who fighting for, the choices you make and whether you're doing what's right for the people. to her it comes international affairs, standing p to trump, making sure we fight to build a better trade agreement that puts canadiens first. for me the question comes do