mr. bruno. i'm a little bit confused what any of what you just said has to do with the permit that is being appealed and i understand we're hearing the two parts of this appeal separately. but this is the housekeeping appeal. but what do any of these housing violations , even assuming it to be true, have to do with this particular permit? oh, good question, because as you know, in the appeal that i gave you, i think i showed very solidly that a housekeeping unit is not a relevant, not applicable, not available rather to this owner or this permit holder not available at all. and since i got the message by email yesterday from mr. green in building that seems to comply agree with what i said. the only issue that still exists is that the if he were to go back and get an adu application in, i'm asking this board to note that it requires a staging area to do it properly so there's no fire that's all. thank you. okay thank you. president swig has a question. yeah, just clarification. so so the grounds