mr. butler. mr. butler did receive the news. he didn't do anything, both because he hadn't assume any role beyond facilitating admissions -- >> did the prosecutor, i'm not talking about the clerk now. the prosecutor had a filing in connection with the rule 32 motion. at the prosecutor send that to, well, everybody? maples and everybody? >> he did not. the state, and this is at page 26 of the joint appendix. the states are a bit on his out of state counsel and that mr. butler, his local council. when the default occurred, mr. maples directly in prison, which would've been unethical if the state had known or believed that he was represented by counsel of. >> but you seem not to rely on what the state as prosecutor did. it seemed to be the state as prosecutor was recognizing that maples had no counsel. therefore, said she better value habeas, this is how much time have, senator jim. >> ice absolutely agree with you, justice ginsburg. i think that that is further evidence that everybody knew that mr. maples didn't have any local cou